You have to trust the mail service and wait for an appraisal. Always check for a "satisfaction guarantee" that allows you to decline the offer and have your items returned for free. 3. Independent Jewelry Stores

Selling broken jewelry might seem like a lost cause, but damaged gold, silver, and platinum still hold significant value based on their raw material content. Whether it’s a snapped gold chain, a single earring, or a smashed ring setting, several reputable outlets specialize in buying "scrap" jewelry. 1. Local Coin and Bullion Dealers

Coin shops are often the best place to start. Because these dealers trade primarily in the spot price of precious metals, they are usually less interested in the "beauty" of the piece and more focused on its weight and purity. They typically offer some of the highest payout percentages because their business model relies on high-volume metal turnover rather than retail markups. 2. Specialized Scrap Gold Buyers

Look up the current market price for gold or silver before you go so you know if an offer is fair.

If the jewelry is high-end or "designer broken" (e.g., a Tiffany bracelet with a broken clasp), it may be worth more as a repair project for someone else than as scrap metal. Platforms like eBay or Etsy have a market for "as-is" or "for repair" vintage jewelry. This requires more effort—taking photos and writing descriptions—but can net a higher price than the melt value. Key Advice Before You Sell:

Most scrap buyers only pay for the metal weight. If your broken jewelry has valuable gemstones, have them removed first or find a buyer who specifically pays for stones.